Piano World Home Page

Stage vs home digital

Posted By: Anjru

Stage vs home digital - 08/15/19 03:21 PM

Hi.

A bunch of years ago I splurged and bought a Yamaha Dgx 640. After a while I upgraded to a Roland fp7f. Now I’m thinking of upgrading again.

I could go with something like Roland’s Fp90 or a Nord. And I could wait a few months till after NAMM, to see what gets released.

So, a few questions. As a non industry professional, is it easy to get into Namm? I studying piano. But does that qualify me as a student? Or do I need to be enrolled in some college? If so, any here have a workaround?

Next questions, hopefully more interesting.

Since I’m not gigging, there’s no need for a stage piano. Yet I wonder if I’m missing out by not getting one?

all the additional sounds, bells and whistles, layering and such might motivate me to spend more time at the keyboard. But I’m intimidated by all the extra functionality.

how do I go about learning to make use of all the niceties of a stage piano?

By the bye, I did try searching to see if this topic has already been addressed here but didn’t find anything. If it has all I need is a pointer or two?
Posted By: Doug M.

Re: Stage vs home digital - 08/15/19 05:04 PM

Hi Arjru,

No pint in going to NAMM as it's so noisy even with headphones.
You can wait if you want. I would go to a big digital piano shop and test lots of instruments and get a feel for what you value and need.

Kind regards,

Doug.

Ps, Even if something is released at Namm, it won't be available for a while after.
Posted By: Anjru

Re: Stage vs home digital - 08/15/19 06:53 PM

No Pints at NAMM? Maybe if I don’t go liter in the day there’ll be some.

Been to Guitar Center and Sam Ash. They don’t have an Fp90. I could buy one, test it for a month and return it. Not sure I want to go that route just yet.

The piano stores in L.A. don’t seem to have much in the way of digital. More acoustic, Steinways, Bosendorfers, Yamahas, Young Changs, like that. And I haven’t found a digital piano store, at least not specifically.

Hence my interest in NAMM. I figure I might get an idea of what’s out there, even if it’s not the best venue for a sound test.
Posted By: ZeroZero

Re: Stage vs home digital - 08/15/19 07:59 PM

For a stage piano check out the Roland RD2000. This has both beautiful action and beautiful pianos + some very good electric pianos, vintage and a lot more. It's a top pro piasno at a real good price
Posted By: peterws

Re: Stage vs home digital - 08/15/19 08:00 PM

Now and again I have a look in at my local piano shop, to see what's new. So I try out anything of interest, and sometimes stuff I wouldn't normally dream of buying.
There's usually a couple of small grands amongst the digitals, which makes for a decent comparison, touchwise and soundwise.

I believe touch and sound often walk hand in hand, for an acoustic and a digital. A dull piano will feel heavy; you hit it harder to sharpen up the tone and volume, and vice versa.

The current crop of reasonably priced slab pianos (I'll not say stage, because they are multipurpose) are good, and the tone is fuller than one might expect, in most cases. You'll know your DGX was pretty good too, and the action is OK for all but the most demanding pieces, unless you have fat fingers. Most other digitals are better in that respect, so you can't really go wrong.

The home pianos; I found almost all but the cheapest to be unacceptably heavy in tone, to the point of unpleasant. Compared to said baby grands, well, they didn't. The convenience of a slab is a big factor; it'll sit in a corner and still sound good whereas some cabinet pianos need re-siting, or pulling away from the wall. Mind you, they do look good. These are some of my opinions only.
You'll obviously look into this yourself, of course; it's a fun thing to do if you take your time. There's a load of stuff out there. Happy fishing.
Posted By: Charles Cohen

Re: Stage vs home digital - 08/15/19 11:01 PM

How do you learn all the functions and buttons?

. . . You read the manual page by page,
. . . and learn one button (or function) at a time.

Many of the buttons will be useless for you. Some -- like the EQ settings -- might be very nice to have.

Even without all that stuff, a good stage piano (current generation) should sound at least as good as your FP-7F. In particular, the sustain time of the notes is considerably longer on newer DP's -- more like an acoustic piano. And your pedalling will have to adjust to that.

Does the FP-7F have loudspeakers built-in? If so, you'll probably have to get new amps and speakers (or "powered monitors" which contain both) for your new RD-2000 or CP-4 or whatever. Budget for them.

The FP-90 has built-in speakers, reputed to be OK by some users here. You could start with them, and get external amp/speakers if you find them inadequate.
Posted By: Anjru

Re: Stage vs home digital - 08/16/19 06:23 PM

I already have some Yamaha 8” powered speakers. So I’m good there. The fp7f does have built in speakers. Sometimes I play with them all on for a little extra depth.

I’ve been playing with a few different keyboards at my local Guitar Center, the Yamaha cp88, a roland rd 2000 and the Nord stage 3. The roland is certainly more powerful than what I’ve got. The yamaha is a beauty. And the Nord has some awesome sounds. Not sure I need all the additional functionality. I mean, I don’t. But maybe if I were to have it i’d find a use for it?
Posted By: Gombessa

Re: Stage vs home digital - 08/16/19 07:01 PM

Buying a stage piano tends to "save" some money in the low to mid end of the market because you aren't spending money on a big wooden enclosure and heavier shipping. You usually get a lot of extraneous "gigging functions" but you wouldn't be the first to get a stage piano solely for home use.

When you start going up-market ($2500+) is where you begin seeing differences in the cabinets that you can't really get in stage pianos (better sound engines, prelim actions, etc.) But you'll always be paying more for the enclosure, finish and speakers.

There are a lot of good values in home stage pianos imo. As you know, the FP-90 is a great one. So is the Kawai ES8 and the Yamaha P-515 (it's essentially a portable CLP-645). At the high end of the market, the Kawai MP11SE gets you the best action available in a stage format for less than you can get a comparable console with the same action.

So you're in good company with this question, it's a wise one to consider.

PS: when I had a stage piano, I used almost zero of the extra functions. Just turned it on and played piano, as that's all I cared about.
© 2019 Piano World Piano & Digital Piano Forums