Piano Injuries-First Aid - 08/06/13 07:35 PM
Piano Injuries-First Aid
We have all read posts over the last several months from people asking for advice who have experienced repetitive strain injuries (RSI) of one kind or another while playing the piano. I am posting this information because many people have asked or PMd for information about First Aid for pianists’ injuries. Piano World seems to be the ideal place to put this out there.
RSIs are very common among musicians, and they strike students as well as working professionals with equal regularity (1), (2). They strike the high and low, the famous and the not-so-famous. For instance, we have all read or heard about what happened to Leon Fleischer and Gary Graffman in the 1960s and 70s, where RSI severely hampered or curtailed their celebrated careers while they were still young and healthy.(3) RSI also affects the amateur playing piano in their home.(4) Musicians don’t generally like to talk about their injuries, which is why I think there is so little information about them available to musicians. And if you’re a professional who performs regularly, there can be internal and external pressures to hide an injury no matter how severe it is.
The nature and cause of RSI are very well understood. Pianists get RSI for several of the same reasons professional athletes get injured (5):
1- Unvarying repetitive movement patterns
2- Excessive force
3- Awkward postures, poor form or technique
4- Adverse environmental factors e.g. extreme cold, poor condition of equipment, etc.
Both athletes and pianists experience soft tissue injuries such as tendinitis, tenosynovitis, stenosis, bursitis, and others because of these reasons. Sport injuries have a very specific protocol for their treatment that requires immediate First Aid when an injury occurs. This same protocol can be helpful to musicians with recent, sudden-onset injuries. The first round of treatment sports coaches or trainers administer most often follows the RICE protocol (6):
R- rest
I- ice
C- compression
E- elevation
REST eliminates further trauma to the site of injury.
ICE or COLD causes arterioles and capillaries to constrict, limiting the spread of edema.
COMPRESSION stabilizes any joints that are affected, and can help further limit edema.
ELEVATION of the injury above the heart helps speed the flow of oxygen- and nutrient-starved veinous blood and other fluids back to the trunk, further helping to reduce swelling at the injury site.
Over-the-counter pain medication can also be very helpful in speeding recovery. Not only do aspirin, ibuprofen and Tylenol help with pain and discomfort, they also have anti-inflammatory properties that help with swelling. If you use them, follow the instructions on the packaging.
It’s very clear why this protocol works well. The initial stage of injury causes, among other things, the breaking of mast cells that release histamine into the surrounding tissues and fluids. This causes edema, drawing more fluids to the injury site that bring antibodies, nutrients and oxygen to the site of injury. That’s good, because those things speed healing and help prevent infection. But the swelling can progress to surrounding tissues, ultimately impairing circulation. If circulation is compromised, the blood fluids can become exhausted of oxygen and nutrients at the injury site, and also limit the transit of carbon dioxide and waste products out of the affected area. The edema also makes the cells water-logged, affecting their structural integrity and making them more prone to re-injury.
The comparison between pianists and athletes is not perfect. Sports injuries are often multi-joint injuries caused by excessive force and blunt trauma that can be quite severe. Also, athletes most often injure groups of large muscles and the related tissues, whereas musicians injure the small ones. Since that’s the case, compression is probably not necessary for most RSIs of the upper extremity. But the other three are very helpful and can significantly reduce the recovery period.
Additionally, pianists don’t often experience sudden onset, blunt trauma while they play. Rather, they undergo microscopic trauma at a cellular level that their bodies cannot heal completely in a 24-hour period. Since they go back the next day to do the same thing that brought on the micro-trauma, the damage gets worse over time. Finally, it becomes pronounced enough to cause discomfort, pain, swelling, impaired mobility or function. Suddenly, you’ve got tendinitis, or something like it. It may seem like it just “happened†suddenly but, in fact, the injury was building over a long time period.
Here’s another key difference. Posture, form and technique are things that athletes at every level look at and improve regularly, especially after an injury. Coaches and trainers work technical remediation and retraining into recovery programs with every injured athlete, once recovery has progressed sufficiently to do so safely. Pianists almost never do this, and it’s a serious omission. One of the reasons pianists get and stay injured is that they go back to the same movement patterns that injured them in the first place. They don’t change them, so they start playing again and re-injure themselves in the very same way.(7)
If an injury is relatively recent and not severe, then home care can be the option of choice. A home care program should look something like this:
1- Rest. Stay away from playing until the acute symptoms (pain, swelling, loss of mobility) subside.
2- Cold. Use an ice or cold gel pack on the affected area to reduce swelling. Keep it on only long enough to cool the skin to the touch. Repeat as often as two or three times an hour. Don’t put ice directly on the skin as it can cause frostbite.
3- Elevate. If swelling is pronounced, hold the injury slightly above the level of the heart.
4- Retrain. Once you’ve recovered, work with a teacher who can help change your technique so you don’t injure yourself again.
How do you know you’re recovered? Simple: it won’t hurt to play. If it just plain hurts to play, at all, then you are probably not recovered enough to start yet. If the acute symptoms have subsided but it still hurts to play a particular passage, then avoid that passage or texture until you’ve worked with a teacher to retrain the technique. Playing through the pain is always a bad idea.
Lifestyle habits can make healing prolonged or difficult, as well as making you prone to injury. These include:
1- Smoking.
2- High stress
3- Sleep deprivation
4- Poor diet
5- Dehydration, particularly that brought on by excessive alcohol consumption and certain recreational drugs
6- Certain health conditions and drug interactions.
The RICE protocol is intended for recent, sudden-onset pain or injury. You will need to see a doctor if your symptoms don’t improve in a few days, or a week at the outside.
I’m very interested in hearing what your experiences have been. If it’s of interest, we can discuss further on what can be done about more advanced problems of RSI.
---Notes---
1- Zaza, Christine. 1992. "Playing-related health problems at a Canadian music school," Medical Problems of Performing Artists, 7: 48-51.
2- Numerous studies support this view e.g.:
-Driscoll T, Ackermann B, Kenney D, “Sound practice: Injury occurrence and surveillance in orchestral musiciansâ€, [abst.] 28th Annual Symposium on Medical Problems of Performing Artists Proceedings, Denver, CO: PAMA/Rocky Mt. Health Plans (Thu).
-Yeung E, Chan W, Pan F, Sau P, Tsui M, Yu B, Zasa C., “A survey of playing-related musculoskeletal problems among professional orchestral musicians in Hong Kongâ€, Med Probl Perform Art, 1999: 14(1):43-47.
-Ackermann B, Driscoll T, Kenny DT., “Musculoskeletal pain and injury in professional orchestral musicians in Australiaâ€, Med Probl Perform Art., 2012: 27(4):181-187.
3- Dawson, W.J., “The dedicated amateur instrumentalist with upper extremity difficulties [abst.]â€, 19th Annual Symposium on Medical Problems of Musicians and Dancers Procedeings: Education Design (Thu) (Denver, CO, 2001).
4- For those of you who may have missed that, here are a couple of articles: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leon_Fleischer , and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Graffman .
5- http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/tendinitis/DS00153/METHOD=print. Accessed 4Aug13.
6- Ibid.
7- Taubman D., “A teacher's perspective on musicians' injuriesâ€, in Roehmann F. L., Wilson F.R., editors, “The Biology of Music Makingâ€,: MMB Music, pp. 144-153, (St. Louis, 1988).
We have all read posts over the last several months from people asking for advice who have experienced repetitive strain injuries (RSI) of one kind or another while playing the piano. I am posting this information because many people have asked or PMd for information about First Aid for pianists’ injuries. Piano World seems to be the ideal place to put this out there.
RSIs are very common among musicians, and they strike students as well as working professionals with equal regularity (1), (2). They strike the high and low, the famous and the not-so-famous. For instance, we have all read or heard about what happened to Leon Fleischer and Gary Graffman in the 1960s and 70s, where RSI severely hampered or curtailed their celebrated careers while they were still young and healthy.(3) RSI also affects the amateur playing piano in their home.(4) Musicians don’t generally like to talk about their injuries, which is why I think there is so little information about them available to musicians. And if you’re a professional who performs regularly, there can be internal and external pressures to hide an injury no matter how severe it is.
The nature and cause of RSI are very well understood. Pianists get RSI for several of the same reasons professional athletes get injured (5):
1- Unvarying repetitive movement patterns
2- Excessive force
3- Awkward postures, poor form or technique
4- Adverse environmental factors e.g. extreme cold, poor condition of equipment, etc.
Both athletes and pianists experience soft tissue injuries such as tendinitis, tenosynovitis, stenosis, bursitis, and others because of these reasons. Sport injuries have a very specific protocol for their treatment that requires immediate First Aid when an injury occurs. This same protocol can be helpful to musicians with recent, sudden-onset injuries. The first round of treatment sports coaches or trainers administer most often follows the RICE protocol (6):
R- rest
I- ice
C- compression
E- elevation
REST eliminates further trauma to the site of injury.
ICE or COLD causes arterioles and capillaries to constrict, limiting the spread of edema.
COMPRESSION stabilizes any joints that are affected, and can help further limit edema.
ELEVATION of the injury above the heart helps speed the flow of oxygen- and nutrient-starved veinous blood and other fluids back to the trunk, further helping to reduce swelling at the injury site.
Over-the-counter pain medication can also be very helpful in speeding recovery. Not only do aspirin, ibuprofen and Tylenol help with pain and discomfort, they also have anti-inflammatory properties that help with swelling. If you use them, follow the instructions on the packaging.
It’s very clear why this protocol works well. The initial stage of injury causes, among other things, the breaking of mast cells that release histamine into the surrounding tissues and fluids. This causes edema, drawing more fluids to the injury site that bring antibodies, nutrients and oxygen to the site of injury. That’s good, because those things speed healing and help prevent infection. But the swelling can progress to surrounding tissues, ultimately impairing circulation. If circulation is compromised, the blood fluids can become exhausted of oxygen and nutrients at the injury site, and also limit the transit of carbon dioxide and waste products out of the affected area. The edema also makes the cells water-logged, affecting their structural integrity and making them more prone to re-injury.
The comparison between pianists and athletes is not perfect. Sports injuries are often multi-joint injuries caused by excessive force and blunt trauma that can be quite severe. Also, athletes most often injure groups of large muscles and the related tissues, whereas musicians injure the small ones. Since that’s the case, compression is probably not necessary for most RSIs of the upper extremity. But the other three are very helpful and can significantly reduce the recovery period.
Additionally, pianists don’t often experience sudden onset, blunt trauma while they play. Rather, they undergo microscopic trauma at a cellular level that their bodies cannot heal completely in a 24-hour period. Since they go back the next day to do the same thing that brought on the micro-trauma, the damage gets worse over time. Finally, it becomes pronounced enough to cause discomfort, pain, swelling, impaired mobility or function. Suddenly, you’ve got tendinitis, or something like it. It may seem like it just “happened†suddenly but, in fact, the injury was building over a long time period.
Here’s another key difference. Posture, form and technique are things that athletes at every level look at and improve regularly, especially after an injury. Coaches and trainers work technical remediation and retraining into recovery programs with every injured athlete, once recovery has progressed sufficiently to do so safely. Pianists almost never do this, and it’s a serious omission. One of the reasons pianists get and stay injured is that they go back to the same movement patterns that injured them in the first place. They don’t change them, so they start playing again and re-injure themselves in the very same way.(7)
If an injury is relatively recent and not severe, then home care can be the option of choice. A home care program should look something like this:
1- Rest. Stay away from playing until the acute symptoms (pain, swelling, loss of mobility) subside.
2- Cold. Use an ice or cold gel pack on the affected area to reduce swelling. Keep it on only long enough to cool the skin to the touch. Repeat as often as two or three times an hour. Don’t put ice directly on the skin as it can cause frostbite.
3- Elevate. If swelling is pronounced, hold the injury slightly above the level of the heart.
4- Retrain. Once you’ve recovered, work with a teacher who can help change your technique so you don’t injure yourself again.
How do you know you’re recovered? Simple: it won’t hurt to play. If it just plain hurts to play, at all, then you are probably not recovered enough to start yet. If the acute symptoms have subsided but it still hurts to play a particular passage, then avoid that passage or texture until you’ve worked with a teacher to retrain the technique. Playing through the pain is always a bad idea.
Lifestyle habits can make healing prolonged or difficult, as well as making you prone to injury. These include:
1- Smoking.
2- High stress
3- Sleep deprivation
4- Poor diet
5- Dehydration, particularly that brought on by excessive alcohol consumption and certain recreational drugs
6- Certain health conditions and drug interactions.
The RICE protocol is intended for recent, sudden-onset pain or injury. You will need to see a doctor if your symptoms don’t improve in a few days, or a week at the outside.
I’m very interested in hearing what your experiences have been. If it’s of interest, we can discuss further on what can be done about more advanced problems of RSI.
---Notes---
1- Zaza, Christine. 1992. "Playing-related health problems at a Canadian music school," Medical Problems of Performing Artists, 7: 48-51.
2- Numerous studies support this view e.g.:
-Driscoll T, Ackermann B, Kenney D, “Sound practice: Injury occurrence and surveillance in orchestral musiciansâ€, [abst.] 28th Annual Symposium on Medical Problems of Performing Artists Proceedings, Denver, CO: PAMA/Rocky Mt. Health Plans (Thu).
-Yeung E, Chan W, Pan F, Sau P, Tsui M, Yu B, Zasa C., “A survey of playing-related musculoskeletal problems among professional orchestral musicians in Hong Kongâ€, Med Probl Perform Art, 1999: 14(1):43-47.
-Ackermann B, Driscoll T, Kenny DT., “Musculoskeletal pain and injury in professional orchestral musicians in Australiaâ€, Med Probl Perform Art., 2012: 27(4):181-187.
3- Dawson, W.J., “The dedicated amateur instrumentalist with upper extremity difficulties [abst.]â€, 19th Annual Symposium on Medical Problems of Musicians and Dancers Procedeings: Education Design (Thu) (Denver, CO, 2001).
4- For those of you who may have missed that, here are a couple of articles: http:/
5- http:/
6- Ibid.
7- Taubman D., “A teacher's perspective on musicians' injuriesâ€, in Roehmann F. L., Wilson F.R., editors, “The Biology of Music Makingâ€,: MMB Music, pp. 144-153, (St. Louis, 1988).