Piano World Home Page Forums Our Most Popular Forums Pianist Corner Franz Liszt Hungarian Rhapsody No 2

Ahhh.. youth.

I wish I knew now, as much as I did when I was his age.

I honestly doubt that you are over the age of 13. That's pretty generous too.

At the risk of being called a nosey newcomer, I think a read through of virtuoso418's posts will show that the grammar and syntax are far beyond even the most able teenager.
Coherence and maturity are usually highly correlated.

"Coherence and maturity are usually highly correlated."

Not really.

why not?

Because anyone could just sit down and spew out a bunch of overused rhetoric and still be an idiot.

Not that I care, really.

NAK

MMSGA, I take it this isn't one of the posts that exemplifies virtuoso418's grammatical skills.

Not that I care, really.

NAK

Haha...

You need to make that your sig.

Ah, but you DO!

Actually, yes. Really...

I'll try, but I don't think it will have the same effect. Here we go...

Eh, I guess it's okay this way.

NO. Not at all.
I know musical geniuses who don't even puncuate. They use the stupid ... marks to seperate thoughts. It's a pain in the *** to read, but some of them give incredible insight and stories. Likewise, there are idiots who take the time to pander to grammer police.

Agreed. But, when you manage to get through the ..., it's worth it.
They are the people who can actually PLAY Campanella after 3 years of study, and not have to obsess over it, to the exclusion of more profitable study and technique development.

Are you a musical genius? And I mean that in the context of your own definitions...

Maybe you COULD play it after 3 years of intense study.

But pandering to the grammar police, (not to mention improving your education), would serve you better, than pandering to your obsessive need to be able to play ONE piece of music, badly.

When you grow up, and mature, you will understand what I, and others, have been hinting at.

Until then, this discussion, and others where you feel defensive, will revolve around vacuous statements and flawed reasoning.

Oh to be young and know everything...

Good luck with the Liszt.

Not that I care, really.

"Are you a musical genius?"
No.

Guys, let me sum up my previous posts, again, so nobody misunderstands me, again.

I could concievably do it with sufficient time and practice, but I choose not to.

Do you plan on returning to it at a later date?
I was mesmerised when I first heard it, many years ago, (along with the 2nd Rhapsody), and really wanted to give it a go.
However, it was obviously way too difficult, and I lost 'faith'. I don't plan on returning to it, as it is more beneficial for me to play other things. Likewise with the rhapsody. At the moment, neither are worth my while...

Mike

You're really overrating it. I think its quite achievable, granted it would take a few months but it's easily plausible for a 3 year pianist to learn it. It's all down to the way they are being taught (its my opinion that students who are pressured to do grades will never be able to catch up with the students who aren't)

The problem with most teenagers (possibly even younger) is how provoked they are with "big" words, if there's such a thing. There are uncommonly used words, but that doesn't make it a big word. I love it when someone has to scrutinize someone else's word choice because it looks like an attempt to look intelligent, but that's a normal accusation.
Me, why do I choose this type of diction? It's simply the influence around me, i'm surrounding by people who speak like that. So i can't help it. But i'm not going to try to convince you if im intelligent or not.

And valaking, I love you how contradict yourself.

Wow, I must really suck then. I mean, I've been playing for maybe 6-8 years and I still haven't mastered the Rhapsody after 6 months of study. Is this way below average or what?

Yeah you suck! :p

No, of course different people have different speeds of learning, its all subjective anyway I was just generalising.

When you say 'haven't mastered' HR2, what do you mean? Learnt all the notes and working on getting it to speed?