Welcome to the Piano World Piano Forums Over 3 million posts about pianos, digital pianos, and all types of keyboard instruments. Over 100,000 members from around the world.
Join the World's Largest Community of Piano Lovers
(it's free)
It's Fun to Play the Piano ... Please Pass It On!
In piano i did that for like after many years. But tips and tricks are learning a god rhyme for it. With your foot stomp and make the sound "taka" for eightnotes. "Takataka" for 16th note and "takata" for triplets. Start using your left hand åretend-playing for keeping with the 16th and right hand for your triplets. This is not easy - so if you are a beginniner. Wait a bit.
I want to learn this one day to get secure in this rhythm. Chopin wrote it for a series - method of methods - which was where about 10 composers wrote pieces for.
It's like this:
Together, left hand, right hand, left hand, right hand, left hand,
I can do 4:3 like this quite easily and there is many threads on it if you look.
I think eventually in a piece you can just let it flow making sure you keep focus on when the notes are together but this takes skills and maybe an etude like the Chopin one above. It is very difficult. Unlike Reddit where every beginner is playing fantasies impromptu badly it can takes many years.
Interestingly I can't play this FI or this nouvelle etude 1 so I think it's harder to maintain this 4:3 polyrhythm for a length of tine. So even when a single 4:3 rhythm is very easy it can be much much harder to maintain it for a piece.
I think it is a reasonable query even if new to piano. Good luck!
You must not have watched the instructional video. You learn to feel the rhythm by counting to 12 and playing each hand at the proper time. That is the beginning step in learning 4 vs 3, and not just on this one video. It is a mathematical problem.
Repeat after me: Pass the f***ing butter. Or, if you are a more genteel kind of person, you can use this alternative: Pass the stinking butter.
Now you are going to drum this phrase with your two hands, left (L) and right (R). You start with left and right together on "Pass" and then you alternate hands on the rest of the syllables: Pass (L, R together) The (R) Stin- (L) -king (R) But- (L) -ter (R)
Do this many times until the polyrhythm gets internalized. There are also lots of online polyrhythmic metronomes that I found helpful, e.g.: Bounce metronome (You need to uncheck the mute box.)
"Playing the piano is my greatest joy...period."......JP
I know how to do it. He is not correct as it is not how to do all polyrhythms. it does not work on all polyrhythms to split to the smallest denomination of a beat. The smaller denominator in 3:4 that you can count is 4. It is not 12. you cannot count or hear 12ths of a beat. Only josh wright can do this. You can draw lines for the three to see where they are played in relation to the 4. It has the feel of what I described above. I'll let the other pianists and teachers give their view.
Repeat after me: Pass the f***ing butter. Or, if you are a more genteel kind of person, you can use this alternative: Pass the stinking butter.
Now you are going to drum this phrase with your two hands, left (L) and right (R). You start with left and right together on "Pass" and then you alternate hands on the rest of the syllables: Pass (L, R together) The (R) Stin- (L) -king (R) But- (L) -ter (R)
Do this many times until the polyrhythm gets internalized. There are also lots of online polyrhythmic metronomes that I found helpful, e.g.: Bounce metronome (You need to uncheck the mute box.)
My other post was referring to dogperson. I agree with you post.
Bingo You started studying the piano in June. Why are you concerned about learning polyrhythms???
I think in a month time, he can start playing some Chopin etudes. He will need to fully master polyrhythm by then. I think a couple of weeks of training should be plenty enough time.
Unless the tempo is extremely slow, I think almost all players just make the first note of each hand's grouping coincide and the rest falls into place naturally and correctly. Certainly that applies for the Fantasie Impromptu and the Nouvelle F minor Etude. IMO most of the above discussion is an example of needlessly complicating something and not the way someone ready to play those pieces does things.
Practicing these 4 vs. 3 sections slowly is a waste of time. If one can't play them at a reasonable fast tempo one should practice hands separately first.
Unless the tempo is extremely slow, I think almost all players just make the first note of each hand's grouping coincide and the rest falls into place naturally and correctly. Certainly that applies for the Fantasie Impromptu and the Nouvelle F minor Etude. IMO most of the above discussion is an example of needlessly complicating something and not the way someone ready to play those pieces does things.
Practicing these 4 vs. 3 sections slowly is a waste of time. If one can't play them at a reasonable fast tempo one should practice hands separately first.
The hands can fall together naturally and correctly IF executing the polyrhythm has become natural. When you are a beginner, it is not natural and you need to learn where the notes should fall.
Unless the tempo is extremely slow, I think almost all players just make the first note of each hand's grouping coincide and the rest falls into place naturally and correctly. Certainly that applies for the Fantasie Impromptu and the Nouvelle F minor Etude. IMO most of the above discussion is an example of needlessly complicating something and not the way someone ready to play those pieces does things.
Practicing these 4 vs. 3 sections slowly is a waste of time. If one can't play them at a reasonable fast tempo one should practice hands separately first.
The hands can fall together naturally and correctly IF executing the polyrhythm has become natural. When you are a beginner, it is not natural and you need to learn where the notes should fall.
Beginners should not be working on 4 vs. 3, and it's hard to find a beginner piece with that problem. That's why there are so many PW posts about the difficulty with that in Chopin's Fantasie Impromptu. I think almost anyone technically ready to play that piece would handle the polyrhythm the way I suggested irregardless of their prior experience with 4 vs. 3. That's the way I approached it although I had little or no experience with 4 vs.3 at the time.
Bingo You started studying the piano in June. Why are you concerned about learning polyrhythms???
Originally Posted by pianoloverus
Beginners should not be working on 4 vs. 3, and it's hard to find a beginner piece with that problem.
I would like to emphasize this point. BingoDingo why are you trying to do all these things that are normally learned only after a couple of years - voicing, legato chords, and now polyrhythms? If you expect your progress to be better you're in for some disappointment. It's more likely that you will build up tension that leads to bad technique, which it seems is already the case since you complained about pain in one of your previous posts. Maybe it's time to forget about this stuff and focus on your basics first, don't you think?
I've learnt quite a time ago that an adult leopard never changes its spots.
I believe the OP is just about ready to tackle Islamey (the unsimplified version, though I don't know of any other) in about ten days' time. By then, he'll have mastered prime number polyrhythms like 7:11 and 13:17.
