Welcome to the Piano World Piano Forums Over 3 million posts about pianos, digital pianos, and all types of keyboard instruments. Over 100,000 members from around the world.
Join the World's Largest Community of Piano Lovers
(it's free)
It's Fun to Play the Piano ... Please Pass It On!
Hello!!! I'm new in this forum, My name is Christian and I'm a pianist, conductor and composer from Argentina. I share with this forum a video from my last concert in Houston. I hope that they like, if you don't like please don't waste your time in comment the video I don't care negative comments. Best Regards for all in this forum!!
Welcome, thanks for posting! And yes, I think it's quite good -- but there are suggestions that could be made, and let me say that the positive comments that you get would be more meaningful if you didn't say basically that we're only allowed to make positive comments!
I didn't say that I only accept positive comments, I'm only say that I don't want negative comments,so I accept Constructive critiques about my interpretation but no suggestions about the orchestra, about the sound recording, about the quality of video, etc. that don't contribute anything! thanks for watch my video!
This is very much a free speech forum, replies can cover a wide gamut. No matter who a pianist is it is impossible to make everyone happy and non-constructive criticism will happen with public exposure.
About your playing, one thing I liked was the absence of the salad tossing I've noticed increasingly in recent years from pianists. This occurs when during the playing a pianist moves one or both hands in a manner identical to that of tossing a salad. There are other things pianists do as well other than toss an imaginary salad. You for the most part don't do any of those other things, and as well it is late here and I don't have a complete tableaux of these to post, so I'll just leave those items out.
I tend to be a bit of a neutralist, so my responses can be under whelming, but I don't do non-constructive criticism either.
What is of most interest are the compositions but I couldn't find any references to them online other than here.
You have really nice hands; I especially like your pinkies.
"A good intention but fixed and resolute - bent on high and holy ends, we shall find means to them on every side and at every moment; and even obstacles and opposition will but make us 'like the fabled specter-ships,' which sail the fastest in the very teeth of the wind." R. W. Emerson
I didn't say that I only accept positive comments, I'm only say that I don't want negative comments,so I accept Constructive critiques about my interpretation but no suggestions about the orchestra, about the sound recording, about the quality of video, etc. that don't contribute anything! thanks for watch my video!
Well, here's some news for you: When you go public you can't exactly go back and certainly you can't control what others will tell you.
Get used to this, or really don't post anything else online.
I'm being harsh lately, aren't I?
EDIT: And to say something nice, just in case: You ARE playing the Rachmaninov concerto (3rd movement) with an orchestra. This alone is a HUGE wow and one that I've not done myself...
This is very much a free speech forum, replies can cover a wide gamut. No matter who a pianist is it is impossible to make everyone happy and non-constructive criticism will happen with public exposure.
About your playing, one thing I liked was the absence of the salad tossing I've noticed increasingly in recent years from pianists. This occurs when during the playing a pianist moves one or both hands in a manner identical to that of tossing a salad. There are other things pianists do as well other than toss an imaginary salad. You for the most part don't do any of those other things, and as well it is late here and I don't have a complete tableaux of these to post, so I'll just leave those items out.
I tend to be a bit of a neutralist, so my responses can be under whelming, but I don't do non-constructive criticism either.
What is of most interest are the compositions but I couldn't find any references to them online other than here.
Thanks for sharing the video!
Thanks for watch the video, I don't know what is this movement of salad tossing please give me a example!! I hate the the movements and confuse interpretation in Lang Lang, this is so dramatic and bored!
Okay, no one else has said it so I will. This belongs under Members Recordings Pianist Corner.
I'm new in this forum so I don't know Where post my video
Originally Posted by Nikolas
Originally Posted by Heliogabalo
I didn't say that I only accept positive comments, I'm only say that I don't want negative comments,so I accept Constructive critiques about my interpretation but no suggestions about the orchestra, about the sound recording, about the quality of video, etc. that don't contribute anything! thanks for watch my video!
Well, here's some news for you: When you go public you can't exactly go back and certainly you can't control what others will tell you.
Get used to this, or really don't post anything else online.
I'm being harsh lately, aren't I?
EDIT: And to say something nice, just in case: You ARE playing the Rachmaninov concerto (3rd movement) with an orchestra. This alone is a HUGE wow and one that I've not done myself...
Well I know that I don't have the control to do that people say beauty things but I think that people could talk whit technique arguments or about interpretation. I supose that is a pianist forum so this forum have pianist of all the world And I really like Share opinions of pianists who loves the music. I played the complete concerto later I'll upload. Thanks for watch the video.
![[Linked Image]](http://www.runemasterstudios.com/graemlins/images/smilielol.gif)
Didn't I just say that?
