Piano World Home Page Forums Our Most Popular Forums Piano Forum 6' Briggs Piano Conundrum...

So...

I went to see a piano today. A 6'2" Briggs piano in striped mahogany. Serial number 34981. I can't find the age, but it's at least 85 years old and hails from Boston. The piano is listed for $800.00

The soundboard is original, but flawless. No cracks, and all the ribs are firmly attached.

The bridges are also flawless, no cracks or signs of trouble.

The hammers have been replaced recently, and while the action is heavy (they obviously never regulated it after replacing the hammers) it is firm and has no "play" or sloppiness that I can feel. It has clearly had work done.

Despite what look like the original strings (no rust), the tone of the piano is surprisingly solid, with great sustain. The fundamentals are strong, and there is no sign of the percussive attack, quick fade, then low volume sustain that is associated with a failed soundboard. The upper treble and lower bass are quite good, actually. For $800, it can't be beat. I would be thrilled to own it...

The problem:

B2 and C3, and to a lesser extend two other keys, have some badly out of tune unisons, and there is evidence that some of the pins have been hammered in.

Am I fooling myself to think that this is anything but a failed pin block? Should I bother spending the money to have a tech look at it?

I assume the cost of a pinblock is at least $1000.00-$2000.00, would it be worth it to have it replaced in this piano, assuming everything else is fine? Could I get a decent 6' grand for less than the cost of this one and a pin block/strings?

I would be thrilled to own this piano, if it can be tuned.

Did somebody mention bring a tech? If you really like it and there's no obvious other problems..

I'm debating whether it's even worth it to bring a tech: 85 year old piano, a good make but no name recognition; 95% probability that some sort of repair will be needed - at least larger pins (and then strings, of course), if not a whole new block.

Is a piano this age and brand worth repairing?

I should also mention, it will need refinishing. But I can handle that. I'm quite the re-finisher...

Is it worth it as an investment? NO. Is it worth it for you? Only you can answer that.

I'm not a tech but new block, doesn't that in most cases also mean restringing?

Hi Frank,

Here is my meager .02...

$800 for a 6 footer that sounds good and plays pretty good is a really cheap price. You could easily blow that much on a weekend mini-vacation.

The loose tuning pins can be dealt with (if that is all it is and the pin block is not split or cracked) a couple of ways; The CA (super-glue) treatment works well, or at least it did for me on an old upright I fixed up. Also, you can go to a larger size tuning pin, most likely.

I agree that it would be worth it to have a tech check it out for you. As much as I like a bargain on a piano, you won't enjoy it if it won't hold a tuning for very long.

Good luck and keep us informed!

Rick

Thanks, all!

Yes, wimpiano, the strings would have to be replaced if it was re-pinned or blocked.

Rickster: thanks for your $0.02. $800 is a good price, isn't it. Best case scenario, we're talking a CA treatment and regulation. I guess in that case, it would probably be worth it.

This would be an easier decision if the piano was in my tech's service area, but it's not. I trust my tech very much, but for this piano, I will have to blindly choose from the two or three people in the vicinity (Ormond Beach, FL).

There are some other good deals around, too. For $1995.00 I can get a 5'2" 1913 Vose and Sons piano that has been restored, including: new pins, new strings, new hammers, new keytops, refinishing. But a 5'2" piano is a whole different - and inferior - animal than a 6'2"... I'm going to see it anyway. Maybe that will make the decision easier...

After bouncing things off the wall, and you all here, I called a tech. So I will have an update on my little piano adventure on the 14th.

Good call, Frank. It's worth having a tech look at it.

Good luck!

Thanks OperaTenor!

You might invest in a pin gauge. That way you can check if larger pins are an option or whether it's already maxed out. It may also impress the seller with your expertise. ;-)

Ha! Oh, I'm pretty sure I intimidated the sellers. I was looking at the piano with my brother (He also plays. Good to have two pairs of hands, ears, and eyes) and explained out loud the workings and condition of every part of the piano I was examining. The terminology was flying. By the time I got to talking bout the agraffes, the sellers, who were standing by listening, were practically shaking.

I've been following these forums for several years, waiting for this moment. What is it they say about a little bit of information?

Well, Frank, you and I might be in the same boat with the "little bit of knowledge" syndrome. Thing is, knowing a little bit about pianos is still a lot more than most people know.

Good luck!

Rick

Big warning signs here.
Hammers need to be carefully matched in size, weight and felt characteristics to each instrument. Otherwise, the touch and tone may never meet expectations. And playing piano is all about touch and tone.

Heavy touch after hammer replacement is a tell-tale sign of incorrect hammers with too much mass, and/or incorrect hammer shank geometry. Regulation will not help in this case. This is widely misunderstood issue. You cannot regulate away hammer mass or compensate for incorrect geometry. Things can get pretty involved and the problem needs to be properly diagnosed and fully understood.

A technician should take a close look at the action geometry and weights of the individual components.

Sorry if this is dumb question, but in the interest of educating myself, what does is mean that the pins have been hammered in?

-Michael

Take this with a grain of salt (I'm not a tech), but I'm 99.999% sure this is an accurate answer:

When a piano's tuning pins start to get a little loose, some techs attempt to fix the problem (or at least mitigate it) buy hammering the pins deeper into the pin block.

Thanks for this! I will add this to my notes.

I have a question, though. Forgive me if the answer is obvious. I know nothing about action geometry.

Will a tech be able to tell, without being able to see the original hammers/shanks, whether the new ones are correct? If not, I doubt any information will be readily available for a 80-90 year old Briggs. The company went out of business in 1929.

Short answer - it is an investigative/diagnostic process. Not all tuners are up to this task.

At a certain point, it could become cost prohibitive on a no-name $800 piano, it depends on the situation.

Or you could buy the piano and simply live with the heavy action.

Thanks! Let's see what he says. This is that moment when I wish my regular tech, in whom I have great confidence, would drive as far as the beach.