Welcome to the Piano World Piano Forums Over 3 million posts about pianos, digital pianos, and all types of keyboard instruments. Over 100,000 members from around the world.
Join the World's Largest Community of Piano Lovers
(it's free)
It's Fun to Play the Piano ... Please Pass It On!
You're cranky old men who like to go around finding things to criticize, both of you.
If you don't want to be criticized for inappropriate and obnoxious comments then you should avoid making them.
Who do you think looks obnoxious here? Nobody else seemed to have a problem with my comment, and as Old Man said, if you hadn't brought it up then there wouldn't be an issue.
You're cranky old men who like to go around finding things to criticize, both of you.
If you don't want to be criticized for inappropriate and obnoxious comments then you should avoid making them.
Who do you think looks obnoxious here? Nobody else seemed to have a problem with my comment, and as Old Man said, if you hadn't brought it up then there wouldn't be an issue.
Another other poster strongly agreed with me immediately after I made my post. Your "nobody else" comment is false.
And this is not the first time you have made comments like this. Far from it. In fact, in this very thread right before my post another poster called another comment you made about a different issue "unbecoming".
I'm glad to hear the OP has no problem with your comment, but I certainly think others receiving such a comment might not feel the same. If I thought there was no chance he would be hurt by your comment, I would not have responded the way I did. I think he was being quite generous.
You're cranky old men who like to go around finding things to criticize, both of you.
If you don't want to be criticized for inappropriate and obnoxious comments then you should avoid making them.
Who do you think looks obnoxious here? Nobody else seemed to have a problem with my comment, and as Old Man said, if you hadn't brought it up then there wouldn't be an issue.
Another other poster strongly agreed with me immediately after I made my post. Your "nobody else" comment is false.
And this is not the first time you have made comments like this. Far from it. In fact, in this very thread right before my post another poster called another comment you made about a different issue "unbecoming".
Actually, I think Cinnamonbear was using irony to agree with Polyphonist's logic. But that was just my take. I could be wrong.
And normally I would agree with the substance of what you were saying. But Mark had already used the same phrase, so I think it's one of those kinds of phrases that "trips off the tongue" (okay, "fingers") in this type of situation, so I don't think either Mark or Polyphonist had any ill intent. For some of us, this freshman recital sounded more like a senior recital, so I think it would seem very natural to add that qualifier.
I doubt that Polyp-honist meant anything by it, and I'm sure the "qualifying phrase" would've gone largely unnoticed had you not shined a GIANT SPOTLIGHT on it.
Actually it hit me over the head big-time, before I saw any 'spotlighting.'
But actually the whole thing could be my fault, because I had said "for a freshman recital" (although together with "especially") and I wondered if maybe Poly was just taking off from that.
[...] Actually, I think Cinnamonbear was using irony to agree with Polyphonist's logic. But that was just my take. [...]
Nope. No irony this time, my friend. I was (and am) irritated by Polyphonist's presumption and what I am beginning to think of as a lack of grace in his posts, when considered cumulatively.
Donald, I have been eager to listen to this ever since you posted it. (It was a long weekend of phone line issues, with up and down internet service. Now that my internet is back to being consistent, I can finally listen, and...) I like what I'm hearing! First of all, what a prodigious program! I listened to the Bach and Beethoven, then skipped to the Debussy (gotta bolt to work this morning. Thanks for the clickable times in the description--that's slick!). Your execution of those three selections alone make quite a statement. Obviously, you are serious, you are capable, and you are committed. What I hear is very impressive, very solid and purposeful playing! Well done.
I'll be back to listen to the rest later. I apologize for my part in messing up your recital thread with the all-too-common PW social detritus. Please keep posting here so we can enjoy your music making and track your progress! More comments to follow...
I listened to the Bach and Beethoven, then skipped to the Debussy
what whatwhat!!!
LOL! You must know how I feel about Liszt by now!... (More Brahms!!!) However, I am primed to appreciate Donald's realization when I listen later tonight.
Cinnamonbear (I love your username, by the way!), thank you so much! I actually love Kapustin. I want to play his jazz variations one day! One of our doctoral students played them at her last recital, and I was hooked from the opening theme.
Donald Lee III BM '16 James Madison University MM '18 Cincinnati Conservatory of Music
Now that my internet is back to being consistent, I can finally listen, and...) I like what I'm hearing! First of all, what a prodigious program! I listened to the Bach and Beethoven, then skipped to the Debussy (gotta bolt to work this morning. Thanks for the clickable times in the description--that's slick!). Your execution of those three selections alone make quite a statement. Obviously, you are serious, you are capable, and you are committed. What I hear is very impressive, very solid and purposeful playing! Well done. 
