Piano World Home Page Forums Our Most Popular Forums Digital Pianos - Electronic Pianos - Synths & Keyboards Mini digital grand piano

I am planning to buy a mini digital grand piano. It has to be a mini digital grand piano (not an up right or a simple keyboard). My budget goes from 3k to 5k. So far I have these three in the list (based on the recommendation of an expert)

Yamaha CLP465GP (Price: 5,000)
Samick SG-310 (Price: 3,000)
Omega LX802 (Price: 4,500)

How the instrument sounds matters the most to me. I have been told that there is no way mini digital grand piano can give you the feel of a grand piano but they do sound like grand piano. I have never played grand piano and am a beginner. Should it matter too much to me if I get the same feeling as of grand piano (I don't even know how it feels for now)????
I will try out Yamaha in my local area but I haven't found anyone who has Samick or Omega in Nj or Pa. Therefore, it'd be great if I can get some input here.
The reason Yamaha and Omega are more expensive is because they have 128 polyphone (can someone explain what this means) and Samick has 64. On the other hand, Samick has 6 speakers with 120 watts while yamaha and Omega has 4 speakers with 80 wattss.
Does having more speakers and watts produce better sound???

Thanks

May I ask why you are only considering a digital grand piano and you're a beginner?



So are you just looking for a mini Grand just for aesthetics?

I've never heard of the Omega, and I was unaware that Samick makes digital pianos.

But the CLP465 is grossly overpriced at $5000. It's equivalent to Yamaha's cheapest Clavinova (around $2000) dressed up in a mini-grand cabinet. Would you pay $3000 extra for that cabinet?

Note that even for this piano, $5000 is beyond reason. You could offer the dealer less, perhaps $3000. (Remember, the high-priced pianos are not sold at a "fixed price". You have to make your own deal.)
The CLP465 will give you neither the feel nor the sound of a grand piano.

Yes I'm a beginner. I'm considering digital because they are cheaper than Acoustic. I could also go with Up-right but my wife likes the grand look (welcome to married life).

Mac,
I was aware of the fact that CLP465 or any other digital piano won't give the same feeling but I was under impression that they would sound the same (more or less).
Can you please explain how CLP465 is same as cheapest Clavino? Did you compare the specs?
Since you said CLP is not going to sound like grand, which one do you think is best within $5,000 range?
Thanks

Kawai CS9, Roland LX15, Yamaha CLP80 are all aesthetically pleasing. Aso excellent pianos. Uprights! I think they look better than those attempts to recreate a grand piano look in a mini style, and would consider them. But I'm not married to your wife.

Kawai CS9. Or you might get close(ish) to a Yamaha AvantGrand N1 at the top of your budget. The three pianos you mention will be very mediocre - almost insulting given their high price.

Your wife might prefer the "grand" look but show her something in polished ebony (like the two above) and I'm sure she'll warm to them - both look very classy.

Good luck,

Steve

Unfortunately the Kawai CS9 is not available in the US.

Tut. What's the one below it James? Or there's CA-93 (although that is satin black).

Yep. I just checked the site. CS9 is not available here.

CLP-465 is, AFAIK, the same piano as CLP-440. It has the new RGE sound engine which is Yamaha's equivalent to Roland's SuperNatural and it's, in my opinion, very good (in the digital cathegory). But their weakest point is the action: both 465 and 440 have GH3, a ten years old digital piano action that is, in my opinion, not bad but unrealistic and difficult to control.

If you like the furniture (I also think it's a good looking one), I think that the 465 is not a bad option within your budget but I'd have in account that the action of the 465 is not as good as that on the cheaper CLP-470 (but this one without the grand furniture).

I like much more Roland RG-1F because I like a lot more the action but its more expensive. I never tried both Omega and Samick.

Yes, CA93 is the top-of-the range soundboard model, the CS6 is the top of the range ebony polish model. I honestly don't know why Kawai America decided not combine both popular characteristics and market the CS9.

Kind regards,
James
x

Too much nihonshu last night, James?

I think I know what you mean.

Tell your wife the grand piano option is the Yamaha N3. If you can afford it, splurge and enjoy the best digital pianos have to offer.

Oh dear.
That'll teach me not to post on the forum until I've had my morning cuppa.

James
x

The only way to know is to try one yourself. Don't buy until you try.
Someone else pointed out that the CLP465 is not equivalent to the low-end Clav. It's actually equivalent to the CLP440, a step up from the bottom.

But the CLP440 can be had for $2500. So, to correct my earlier question ... Would you pay $2500 more for mini-grand cabinet? (Instead of $3000 more, as I implied earlier.)

If you really want a piano that sounds "close" to a grand, try the Yamaha Avant Grands. They start at around $8000.

If that's too much, try the Kawai CA63 or CA93, both well under your $5000 limit. In that price range, nothing from Yamaha or Roland can compare.

My wife also talked me into a Yamaha "mini-grand" for my digital piano because she liked the way it looked in our living room. I'm glad she did. I have to admit, I like the way it looks too now. So listen to your wife. They have a good sense of things like that. Besides, it's much cheaper to replace a piano than a wife.

The top of the line Yamaha "mini-grands" sound "pretty good" and their keyboard feel isn't bad at all. The N1/2/3 have better keyboard actions for sure, but their sound isn't that much better than the top of the line CLP/CVPs mini-grands (and there are issues with the N-series when using their speakers with software pianos, which would mean more to me than the differences in their built-in samples). As a beginner the difference in those keyboards won't matter much unless you have fairly high aspirations for developing your playing ability (and in that case you may eventually want an acoustic piano anyway). I'm not sure how much the keyboards vary from the top to the bottom of the CLP mini-grand line.

As far as sound goes, the top-of-the-line mini-grands have better sound than the bottom of the line mini-grands both in sample-set depth and speakers. So you may want to consider that in what you spend. But if you aren't satisfied with the built-in samples you can use software based virtual pianos for better sound.

However, if you don't like the speaker/amplifier systems in the mini-grand (which should be better than the consoles, because of the speakers and also the orientation of the speaker placement - which is another reason to get a mini-grand) then it becomes more difficult and perhaps aesthetically displeasing to your wife to add external speakers, etc. So that could be a reason to buy a more expensive mini-grand rather than a less expensive mini-grand. In my personal case, I knew before buying that I would never be happy with the built-in samples and would use the piano as a MIDI keyboard for software pianos, but I picked a model that did have pretty good speaker/amplifier system to avoid adding separate speakers.

so now they are to to tell us what we are supposed to play on too?

Out of those three only the Yamaha should be seriously considered as the others are noname brand stuff.
That said the Yamaha isn't exactly a good DP .... far better DP's can be had for 1/3 the price.
But you want a mini grand so your going to pay triple the price to get half the board.

Sheraz Khan, you can buy a real acoustic new grand for around 6k$ in NJ...